This forum is for general topics. Keep all posts, images, etc safe for those who read the forum at work. Post only that content that you'd want your mama to read. Violators will be banned.
By D. Micus
#77291
Continuing in the good reads tradition, what are some books that were big disappointments? I have a few:The Compleat Angler--i think ike walton wrote this to discourage others from fishing! i've tried to read it 100 times and can't get past the first 10 pages.Dream Fish and Road Trips--E. Donnal Thomas takes himself way to seriously.True Love and the Wooly Bugger--David Ames is probably a hell of a guide, but he's no writer.Fly Fishing Through Midlife Crisis--Howell Raines does what journalists do best--writes like an expert on a topic he doesn't seem to know much about.The Moon Pulled Up an Acre of Bass--Peter Kaminsky's 250 page advertisement for Montauk guides.(There, got that out of my system!)
By Surly
#77292
Anything by Charles Meck. All of his "stories" are the same; no one catches any fish until he gets there and decodes the multiple-species-masking-hatch with a #14 Patriot.
User avatar
By Smithhammer
#77293
"The Complete Book of Fly Fishing" by Tom McNallyJust dull, and filled with more stories about himself than useful info. I find Rand McNally far more interesting.
By hotspur
#77294
At the risk of being smitten from this board (and perhaps the earth), could we put Gierach on this list? He has written the same story over and over again for the past ten years: formulaic dimestore wisdom with buddy bonding thrown in. Now if we go back to his beginnings and let him wax over things like Camp Coffee, then there's something to it. My hypothesis: he has made too much easy money. Some real talents have sold out, but they didn't do it with their writing. (Jim Harrison hawks luggage for Orvis; David Foster Wallace caught Frank(?) Conroy writing brochures for cruise lines. Neither of these guys got sucked into the Part II syndrome: 'People bought that last one; hell, they'll buy this one, too...')Oh, and since you all hate me now, we can add anything James Prosek has written to the list of Bad Reads.
By Brookwookie
#77295
Originally posted by D. Micus:n True Love and the Wooly Bugger--David Ames is probably a hell of a guide, but he's no writer.
You and I are now mortal enemies. Your soul is a yawning howling void from which light cannot escape. I can only assume that your own ability to write, so aptly demonstrated in the latest Drake, was acquired in some deal with a lesser devil or nightgaunt in exchange for puppy heads, dead roses and pocket change.Just kidding. I like Ames though.
User avatar
By MassBass
#77296
I enjoy Ames but I know nothing about good writing as I enjoy reading The Drake.Everybody knows the drake is crap so I'm hopeless.
By Brookwookie
#77297
Originally posted by hotspur:n could we put Gierach on this list? He has written the same story over and over again for the past ten years...My hypothesis: he has made too much easy money.
I can see your point, but I'll never begrudge a guy who's made money like he has. IMO, his stuff might be formulaic, but it rarely fails to entertain me and never plunges to the level of a "bad read". I think he's exactly the kind of writer that should be rewarded with lots of cash.
By Salty
#77298
Concerning the Gierach views posted, IMHO, its not that it is a "bad read" but that its a dimishning return. I bought "Death Taxes and Leaky Waders" and really liked it because it was the first book of his that I read, but as I read more of his books, it did become repetitive and formulaic. I also agree that the earlier stories he wrote were better. I wouldn't worry about being banned from this board for an opinion- I admited using a spinning rod yesterday and was allowed back, and so far this morning's tally includes HST petting a badger, strippers, and rotting coho, not bad for hostility tuesday.
By Surly
#77299
Originally posted by hotspur:n Oh, and since you all hate me now, we can add anything James Prosek has written to the list of Bad Reads.
Seconded. I received his book about a trip to England in search of Walton. I suffered through the first hundred pages, then summarily burned the dammed thing on a camping trip. My impression; he thinks he can take a shit, wrap it in a dust jacket, mention his Yale degree and sell it at Barnes & Noble.
By Capn Crooks
#77300
I think Gierach is what I would classify as "easy reading",the kind of book that doesn't challenge you but is entertaining enough anyway.I gotta agree about Walton though...to quote Gierach..."he was a bank napping bait fisherman"
By D. Micus
#77301
and to quote paul (in "a river runs through it") "the bastard doesn't even know how to spell complete!"
By unclejesse
#77302
Third for Prosek. I read "Fly-fishing the 41st" and the writing style was pretty flat. Maybe I am just envious that the guy gets to travel the world, catch exotic trout, and hook up with women all because he is good with watercolors. I do like some of his paintings though.
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 7
Winter steelhead fly swap 2019

Bump FFS

Thumbing Through Some SBSs

Red Headed Kate McLaren Muddler https://liv[…]

A Confession

That is so funny......his suits are more offensive[…]

whatcha tying?

Fokker...rooibaard

Subsribe to The Drake Magazine